Claire's Catholic Conspiracy Coverage

On 5 March 2021, Claire Giangravé wrote a conspiracy theory opinion piece for Religion News Service.

Photo G Sutton Vatican 2019

In this post, I comment on a problem with articles like this one that offer selected quotes from people as a basis for supporting a premise without any obvious attempt to counterbalance the voices or either offer supporting data or a statement of limitations where there are no data.

In short, readers are left with the notion that the author has presented factual news when we mostly have a collection of opinions. Following is the RNS title.

Where is the evidence for a "breeding ground" that warrants singling out the Catholic church as worthy of an opinion article in a news source?

Her opening statement offers a premise that allows us to pause and consider if the statement is true or false:

"If it’s true that all roads lead to Rome, it’s also true that in one way or another, all conspiracy theories lead to the Vatican."

In a literal sense, the statement is false. In a metaphorical sense, it isn't very helpful. Perhaps she just wanted to get our attention with a catchy phrase?

How useful are experts?

In the third paragraph, we learn about her news sources -- "experts."

I realize we all rely on experts for one thing or another. The problem we all have is which experts really know the truth about one thing or another.

At least in the best scientific studies, the experts are referring to studies which we can read and evaluate the evidence. In this article, we are limited to the experts selected by the author.

I am looking for experts to give me some data but what I get are opinions. Now, to be fair to the author, so many news stories interview experts to get an opinion on something. Sadly, we rarely know enough to challenge either the credibility of the expert or the data that form their opinions.

Is there really a "perfect storm?"

It isn't worth it to me to challenge the rhetoric of a perfect storm. So, Catholics have had some challenges. I'm not a Catholic but I follow the news and know the events she mentions.

I do not see any data suggesting the Catholic tradition is any more fertile than the imaginations of humans in religious and nonreligious groups as a result of their perfect storm.

How useful are the data?

As you read on, below the stunning photo of St Peter's Square, there's a reference to Pew Research, which happens to be before the recent explosion of conspiracy theories (did you notice the date?). A tiny percentage of "cradle American evangelicals" became Catholics (2%). There's an unidentified "small cohort" of Protestants opposing the current Pope.

So, 98% of Catholics did not come from American evangelical stock.

How big is the conspiracy problem in the church?

When all is said and done, we are left with the author's belief that there is a substantial problem with conspiracy theories in the Catholic church.

We have no data documenting the size of the conspiracy problem and no comparison to anything that might give us a clue that Catholics have a troublesome storm or "perfect storm" that is somehow raging out of control.

We have opinions. They can become hypotheses. In my view, the best case for articles like this is to consider opinions as hypotheses to be tested.

Perhaps some Catholic scholars will offer some data. It would be interesting to know the nature and extent of conspiracy theories within the church.

Links to Connections

I write about the intersection of psychology and religion. Join me in the discussion or the sharing of research and news.

Checkout My Website www.suttong.com

See my Books

AMAZON

GOOGLE STORE

JOIN me on

FACEBOOK Geoff W. Sutton

TWITTER @Geoff.W.Sutton

PINTEREST www.pinterest.com/GeoffWSutton

Read many published articles:

Academia Geoff W Sutton

ResearchGate Geoffrey W Sutton

SPIRITUAL ABUSE: An Investigation

Investigating Spiritual Harassment and Abuse WP Post Article In an exclusive article, Ian Shapira reported on problems within the US Anglican Church (2025, October 24). Two leaders in the Anglican church are identified early in the WP report. [Ruch, who has been a bishop for 12 years, is one of two top leaders in the continent’s Anglican denomination confronting allegations of wrongdoing. The other is its senior-most official, Archbishop Stephen Wood. A married father of four sons, Wood, 62, has been accused by a former employee of trying to kiss her last year inside his church office in South Carolina, according to a new church presentment, which The Washington Post obtained in advance of its Monday submission. The accusations, which include plagiarizing sermons and demeaning colleagues, could prompt an ecclesiastical trial against Wood and his removal from ministry, according to the denomination’s laws. (Shapira, 2025).] ***** My concern is for people who have exper...

Marriage Under Reconstruction

The 1950s imaginary sentimental love man as protein-carbs winner (bring home the bacon & breadwinner) marriage has ended for most people in most Western cultures. Some folks retain that image, or some photoshopped version of it, as the ideal traditional marriage. Picture the happy couple at church with King James Bibles under their arms and you get the Protestant Christian version of this traditional marriage. Changes are a constant The changes in marriage and romantic relationships in the last few decades are staggering for anyone alive before the 1960s. Human behavior is my business. I am a psychologist. The counseling advice offered to couples seems to reflect the mythology of the decade rather than recommendations sourced in science. I would like to say that the nature and extent of the changes in marriage and romantic relationships have never been seen before in human history. But I am no historian. Nevertheless, the changes call for some consider...

EASTER: VARIATIONS IN BELIEF

Differences in Religious & Spiritual Beliefs Relevant to the Easter Story By Geoffrey W. Sutton, Ph.D. at suttong.com Like most Christians, my wife and I attend an Easter Service. And, a s usual, the media rise to the Spring occasion with Bible stories, comments from various religious leaders and a few atheists—just to keep things balanced. Other religions are on the back burner until Monday. So many statements of beliefs come from the Easter events. For now, here’s a sample of some core beliefs from various sources. God: 51% believe in God as in the Bible Statista (May, 2023) reported US belief "in God as described in holy scriptures" at 51%. Another 22% reported a belief in a higher power or spirit. Pew researchers from 2021 find 58% believe in God as described in the Bible and another 32% believe in a God or Higher Power. Belief in God is obviously a core belief. U.S. belief has declined to 58% having no doubt God exists and another 17% have do...

Geoffrey W. Sutton PhD, Psychology and Culture

Search This Blog