Psychology of Religious Testimony

Religious testimonies are like stories of good news. We enjoy celebrating good news when we know the family. A recent study might explain a decline in public testimonies.

Imagine visiting a group of Evangelical Christians who are about to study the Gospel of John. They sit on hard plastic chairs while chattering about the weather, problems at work, and some aggravating post on social media. At some point, a leader asks the group to share their news stories and prayer requests. They’ll pray before beginning their Bible study. One woman tells the details of a sister struggling with cancer—she’s not expected to live. There is a concerted sigh of sadness. A man mentions worries about finding work. Heads nod in sympathy. Someone makes a note. Then an excited woman has some good news. She has a large smile on her face as she announces, “We’re pregnant!” She’s gesturing to her husband whose grin widens as his face reddens in response to all the attention. Smiles spread around the group. The good news lightens the mood. Eventually, the long list of pain and suffering dominates the prayer.

In decades past, Pentecostals stood in worship services to share their testimonies of what God had done for them. The spiritual stories were often about recovering from an illness or someone getting converted. Others reported finding work or another life blessing. In recent years, Pentecostals and other evangelicals are likely to share their good and bad news in small group meetings like the fictional example above.

The psychology of testimonies is related to the psychology of emotion and something psychologists call symhedonia, which contrasts with sympathy. Edward Royzman and Paul Rozin of the University of Pennsylvania found that unlike our capacity to respond with sympathy toward people who have experienced tragedy—even people who are strangers, it is more difficult to share in a celebration of joy (that is symhedonia) unless we have an emotional connection to the one reporting the joyful experience.

The finding by Royzman and Rozin (2006) fits well with the shift in testimonies. Praying for people with various needs continues in services large and small. It is easy to respond to troubling experiences. But those old services where people stood up and shared personal good news have largely been replaced in large congregations by sharing stories in small groups. This makes sense. The personal connections in small groups not only enhance compassion but they also increase the experience of joy.

Advertisement

Books by Geoffrey Sutton on AMAZON.

It’s hard to have a close connection with hundreds of people in mega-congregations. Sympathetic responses still evoke compassion. But small groups have the edge when it comes to testimonies of joy.

Reference

Royzman, E. B., & Rozin, P. (2006). Limits of symhedonia: The differential role of prior emotional attachment in sympathy and sympathetic joy. Emotion, 6(1), 82-93. doi:10.1037/1528-3542.6.1.82

Marriage Under Reconstruction

The 1950s imaginary sentimental love man as protein-carbs winner (bring home the bacon & breadwinner) marriage has ended for most people in most Western cultures. Some folks retain that image, or some photoshopped version of it, as the ideal traditional marriage. Picture the happy couple at church with King James Bibles under their arms and you get the Protestant Christian version of this traditional marriage. Changes are a constant The changes in marriage and romantic relationships in the last few decades are staggering for anyone alive before the 1960s. Human behavior is my business. I am a psychologist. The counseling advice offered to couples seems to reflect the mythology of the decade rather than recommendations sourced in science. I would like to say that the nature and extent of the changes in marriage and romantic relationships have never been seen before in human history. But I am no historian. Nevertheless, the changes call for some consider...

SPIRITUAL ABUSE: An Investigation

Investigating Spiritual Harassment and Abuse WP Post Article In an exclusive article, Ian Shapira reported on problems within the US Anglican Church (2025, October 24). Two leaders in the Anglican church are identified early in the WP report. [Ruch, who has been a bishop for 12 years, is one of two top leaders in the continent’s Anglican denomination confronting allegations of wrongdoing. The other is its senior-most official, Archbishop Stephen Wood. A married father of four sons, Wood, 62, has been accused by a former employee of trying to kiss her last year inside his church office in South Carolina, according to a new church presentment, which The Washington Post obtained in advance of its Monday submission. The accusations, which include plagiarizing sermons and demeaning colleagues, could prompt an ecclesiastical trial against Wood and his removal from ministry, according to the denomination’s laws. (Shapira, 2025).] ***** My concern is for people who have exper...

Why Social Spaces Are Psychological Forces

Louise Penny has noted that Quebec, the setting of her novels, operates almost as a character in its own right. This observation is more than literary flair; it reflects a psychological truth. Environments exert influence. They shape perception, emotion, and behavior. In social psychology, we recognize that human functioning is inseparable from context. Our interactions with others affect our mood, cognition, motivation, and even our physiological health. This is why social context is a core dimension of the SCOPES framework. Yet physical environments — even in the absence of people — also exert measurable effects. Consider how interior spaces communicate safety, warmth, or threat. A familiar chair can regulate stress; a poorly designed one can amplify discomfort. Sensory cues such as scent, sound, and texture influence our emotional states in subtle but powerful ways. Outdoor environments operate similarly. Natural settings often promote restoration, while harsh or polluted environmen...

Geoffrey W. Sutton PhD, Psychology and Culture

Search This Blog