Updated 26 Feb 2018
What Christian Counselors Believe, Value, and Practice
Part I: Beliefs
I once
asked a conservative evangelical Christian Chaplain how he handled counseling
when he was pretty sure a dying patient was not a Christian and, according to his tradition, would soon spend
eternity in hell. He sincerely said he would have to think about that question.
A female health care provider told me she switched jobs so she could work with children rather than seniors, because she believed that, unlike the elderly, children would go to heaven if they died. In this case, her Christian beliefs appeared to have a cause -effect influence on her career.
Counselors
normally focus on the needs of clients and help clients find solutions in a
supportive setting. Theoretically, rapport ought to be enhanced when counselors
and clients share common values and beliefs.
Why ask what
Christian Counselors Believe?
The primary reason
is to address the rapport factor. As noted in a previous post, many Christians
prefer counseling from someone who shares their Christian beliefs and values. When it comes to lifestyles, conservative Christians hold beliefs at variance with the general culture. And some believe that certain ways of living are linked to personal distress.
A secondary reason
is the observation that many people draw strength from their faith; thus, it
makes sense for a therapist to help clients draw on their faith when
applicable. For example, such concepts as forgiveness, hope, gratitude, love,
and reconciliation are of interest to psychologists and people of faith.
A third reason is to explore how beliefs are related to the practice of counseling and psychotherapy.
What is a Christian?
The idea of Christian counseling suggests we ought to know
what we mean by the concept, Christian.
Some people will define Christian by quoting a portion of the Bible. Over the
years, theologians have argued about core beliefs. Arguments over refined
points of doctrine often result in a leader creating a new religious movement
in societies that have freedom of religion. There are creeds and statements of
faith online. In short, some people identify as Christian based on the faith of
their family or their baptism in a particular faith group. Others come to faith
later in life, which may involve a confession of faith and a verbal expression
of some set of beliefs about God and Jesus. Some just say “I’m a follower of
Jesus,” as if to distance themselves from arguments over doctrines.
In this survey, we asked about the religious identity of the
counselors, and we asked about their beliefs. You will see the items are similar to
themes asked of the public in other surveys.
SURVEY QUESTIONS
How do your beliefs
compare to Christian Counselors in the US?
Last year, my colleague Chris Arnzen and I conducted a
survey of Christian Counselors and Psychotherapists from organizations primarily based in
the United States, but includes some members from Canada. Overall we
obtained responses from about 250 people. Some clinicians did not respond to
every item.
I’ll list the questions first in case you would like to record your answers before seeing how the counselors responded. We
asked people to respond on a five-point scale from “Strongly Agree” to
“Strongly Disagree” with each item. Following the questions, I’ll show you
how the counselors responded.
1. I believe Jesus is the son of God.
2. I have had a born again experience.
3. God heals some people without human intervention.
4. All Christians are called to share their faith with others
5. Clients who do not accept Jesus as their personal savior will spend eternity in hell.
And some questions about the Bible
In prior posts about
Christian fundamentalism, I reported that fundamentalists focus on the Bible
(or the sacred texts in other religious traditions) in a close to literal
fashion. And when they make statements about social values and behavior, they
rely heavily upon the Bible with little to no regard for the findings from
science or other disciplines. In short, God’s
Word trumps man’s wisdom. This is the context that led us to include
questions about the Bible. I’ll give you the questions before revealing how the
counselors responded.
Four questions about the Bible as the Sacred Writing for
Christians. As before, we asked for ratings on a five-point scale from
“Strongly Agree” to “Strongly Disagree.” (These are adapted from the 10-item version of the Intratextual Fundamentalism Scale).
1. Everything
in the Sacred Writing is absolutely true without question.
2. The words
of the Sacred Writing have at least some contradictions and/or errors.
3. The
Sacred Writing should never be doubted, even when scientific or historical
evidence outright disagrees with it.
4. If what
the Sacred Writing says disagrees with the findings or discoveries of science,
then what science says is probably closer to what is really true
RESULTS
How did the Christian Counselors respond?
Core faith: Here’s a summary of their answers to questions about
basic beliefs. Scroll up to see the actual questions.
Belief (n = 251)
|
Strongly Agree/Agree
|
Neither or Disagree
|
No
Response
|
1 Jesus is
the Son of God
|
83.7
|
.4
|
15.9
|
2 Born
again experience
|
78.5
|
4.8
|
16.7
|
3 God
heals w/o human
|
96.7
|
3.3
|
15.9
|
4 Christians
called to share faith
|
80.8
|
3.2
|
15.9
|
5 Clients
hell-bound w/o salvation
|
52.9
|
29.5
|
17.5
|
Bible: Here’s how they responded to questions about the Bible (the
generic term is, Sacred Writing). Scroll up to see the four questions.
Belief (n = 251)
|
Strongly Agree/Agree
|
Neither or Disagree
|
No Response
|
1 SW
absolutely true
|
63.7
|
24
|
12.4
|
2 SW some
contradictions/ errors
|
30.5
|
61
|
12.4
|
3 SW never doubt
|
45.2
|
42.8
|
12
|
4 If SW
disagrees w/ findings then science probably true
|
7.7
|
79.9
|
12.4
|
Thoughts
Anyone
who identifies as a Christian
counselor or psychotherapist likely holds conservative beliefs. That’s a
hypothesis. Even though mental health clinicians might identify as a Christian
they may not offer explicitly Christian interventions. But a clinician whose
professional identity is portrayed as a Christian Counselor has claimed
something unique. I want to discover that unique quality and how it impacts
their services.
You can
see that our sample is quite conservative overall, but a significant group of
Christian clinicians do not hew to traditional Christian beliefs. The question
about evangelism (sharing faith) and hell were important to identifying the
level of conservatism within our sample.
Although
heaven and hell are long-standing teachings of the church, nearly half of the
sample did not endorse the belief about salvation and hell as often phrased by
U.S. evangelicals. Of course, I made it personal by referring to clients even as I did when asking the evangelical Chaplain about his beliefs regarding the dying patient. It seems to me, that highly committed Christians who really believe in evangelism and the reality of hell would feel very uncomfortable suppressing the urge to witness in some situations.
Remember my story above about the woman who changed her job to work with children? In case you are unaware, the Bible says nothing explicitly about the age criteria for entering heaven or hell at the end of earthly life unless certain belief criteria are met. But Christians seem to believe a loving God wouldn't hold infants or children responsible for their eternal destiny.
My point is, beliefs matter. And a counselor's beliefs might influence what happens in a counseling session.
When it
comes to the Bible, the counselors are also fairly conservative, although about
one-third did not see the biblical text as absolutely true. The wording of the
items can be debated endlessly, but I think you can get the sense that the
counselors in the survey were divided in terms of doubt. You also see a general unwillingness to accord scientific
findings more weight that the Bible when a perceived conflict occurs.
Findings
like these lead to more questions and a wish that we had asked some questions in a
slightly different way. We did permit open answers on many items so the
counselors could explain a nuanced view.
In
future posts, I will report more about the values of counselors and what they
include as interventions. You can find related papers on my Academia and ResearchGate listings.
Learn how to create surveys: Creating Surveys on AMAZON
Learn how to create surveys: Creating Surveys on AMAZON
Related Posts
References
Sutton, G. W.,
Arnzen, C. A. (2015, April). Evidenced-Based
religious accommodative psychotherapy: Practice and belief. Paper presented
at the annual meeting of the Christian Association for Psychological Studies,
International Conference, Denver, Colorado.
Sutton, G. W., Arnzen, C., & Kelly, H. (2016). Christian counseling and psychotherapy: Components of clinician spirituality that predict type of Christian intervention. Journal of Psychology and Christianity, 35, 204-214. An academic publication related to the topic in this post. Downloads at ResearchGate and Academia
Connect
Website www.suttong.com
Sutton, G. W., Arnzen, C., & Kelly, H. (2016). Christian counseling and psychotherapy: Components of clinician spirituality that predict type of Christian intervention. Journal of Psychology and Christianity, 35, 204-214. An academic publication related to the topic in this post. Downloads at ResearchGate and Academia
Connect
Website www.suttong.com
No comments:
Post a Comment